Food

I Scream, You Scream, We All Scream for Ice Cream!

Five strawberry ice cream scoops, two judges, and one clear winner

One of my favorite sweet treats for as long as I can remember has been ice cream. Growing up in Oklahoma, I had the absolute privilege of eating Braums ice cream on a regular basis—and let me tell you, that place is elite. Truly one of the best ice cream spots ever. (And if you ever find yourself near one, do not sleep on their hamburgers either.) That deep love for ice cream clearly made its way down the family line, because my kids have inherited it right along with me… including a serious appreciation for Braums. It’s hands down one of their favorite treats, and honestly, I can’t blame them.

blind ice cream taste test with kids

But that got us wondering… if we had to choose, which ice cream would reign supreme? Since we don’t have Braums here in Houston, we decided it was time to find out who the local champ really is. We’re practically neighbors with Blue Bell country, which everyone swears by, and the girls and I have grown pretty fond of H-E-B Creamy Creations too. Still, opinions are opinions—so we made it official with a blind taste test. No labels. No bias. Just spoons and serious judgment.

strawberry ice cream taste test

To keep things fair, we picked one classic flavor: strawberry. From there, we grabbed five different ice creams, all from H-E-B. Our contenders were Tillamook ($3.50/pint), Blue Bell ($4.12/pint), H-E-B Creamy Creations ($2.48/pint), H-E-B Swoon ($3.98/pint), and Häagen-Dazs ($4.36/pint). After dinner, we sent the girls out of the kitchen and set up our secret judging station. Each ice cream was scooped into a bowl and placed in a random order. When everything was ready, we called the girls back in, handed them each a spoon, and let the games begin. To say they were excited would be an understatement—especially since dessert on school nights is usually a hard no… but tonight, we made an exception.

As judging began, the girls took their task very seriously. The rule was simple: they had to agree on the final ranking from best to worst—which meant lots of tasting, re-tasting, and deep discussion. Our judges had opinions. The ice cream in the white bowl tasted more like a vanilla base with a hint of strawberry. The green bowl was unanimously declared the creamiest. The light pink bowl was described as “just plain strawberry,” while Everly insisted it was missing “something” (very official critique). The dark pink bowl didn’t have much strawberry flavor at all. Emma was convinced the ice cream in the yellow bowl would be the winner purely because the color was the brightest pink—clearly science was involved. Their commentary was equal parts hilarious and impressively thoughtful.

best strawberry ice cream brand

In the end, there was a clear winner: H-E-B Swoon took first place—and honestly, that surprised me because I had never even tried it before. Second place went to Tillamook, with Blue Bell coming in third. H-E-B Creamy Creations landed in fourth, and Häagen-Dazs came in last, which was probably the biggest shock of the night. It does make me wonder, though… how would Braums have stacked up in this competition? Guess we’ll never know—unless we plan a road trip. Until then, if you’re in the market for some seriously good ice cream, take our advice and grab the H-E-B Swoon. You might just find a new favorite.

Leave a Reply